Hard Candy Stay in Line Blackest Black 12 Hr Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Review

Skin/Hair Type: Oily and occasionally acne-prone/Normal

Hello gorgeous ladies,

After having good luck with so many Hard Candy makeup products in the past, here comes a dud!! I tried the “Metallic Black” version of this same line of eyeliner and I was quite impressed, but this Hard Candy Stay In Line 12 Hr Mechanical Gel Eyeliner in “Blackest Black” is just not good. Before I rant too much about this liner, let’s get into the details of this product.

Hard Candy Stay in Line Blackest Black 12 Hr Mechanical Gel Eyeliner

Claim/Product Description:
Hard Candy Gel Eyeliner in Blackest Black product description

Price:
CAD 10.99 (approximately INR 574).

Ingredients:
Hard Candy Gel Eyeliner in Blackest Black ingredients

rati beauty ad

My Experience with Hard Candy Stay in Line Blackest Black 12 Hr Mechanical Gel Eyeliner:

Packaging: This eye pencil comes in a convenient mechanical twist-up packaging. The sleek and slim look of this pencil is easy to use and travel friendly. It also comes with an outer packaging that has all the details of the product mentioned on it. The body of the eye pencil is color coded to the shade of the eyeliner. There is no sharpening involved, so no product wastage! All in all, the packaging is simple and practical.

Hard Candy Gel Eyeliner in Blackest Black packaging

Texture: This liner has a comparatively hard texture that does not glide smoothly along the lash-line or waterline. This is just not creamy enough for a texture of an eyeliner. When applying on the lower lash line (not lower waterline), it does tug a lot and no matter how much effort and patience I put into building the colour, it just does not show up.

Hard Candy Gel Eyeliner in Blackest Black sharpener

Color and Pigmentation:  The pigmentation is not a dense super color payoff, but it can be built to a good intensity, but only on the hand. On the eyes, it does not show up as much is expected out of a creamy eyeliner. Even after rubbing this along the lower waterline several times, this does not show up!! In the EOTD, I have swiped this at least 12-15 times and then when my eye stated to hurt, I gave up.

Hard Candy Gel Eyeliner in Blackest Black liner tip

Longevity: According to Hard Candy, this liner wears for up to 12 hours straight! But this one does even show up on the eyes, let alone standing by its claim! Whatever little color pay-off is achieved, stays on the lash-line for 1-2 hours and fades after that.

Hard Candy Gel Eyeliner in Blackest Black swatch on hand

Hard Candy Gel Eyeliner in Blackest Black eye swatch

Pros of Hard Candy Stay in Line Blackest Black 12 Hr Mechanical Gel Eyeliner:

  • Simple retractable packaging.
  • Affordable.
  • Easily available in drugstores and online.

Cons of Hard Candy Stay in Line Blackest Black 12 Hr Mechanical Gel Eyeliner:

  • Not the “blackest black” as the brand claims.
  • Does not glide easily.
  • Very less pigmentation.
  • Hard texture.
  • Not safe for rubbing on the eye 30 thousand times to get some color pay-off!!
  • Terrible staying power.
  • Not as creamy as I would like.
  • Tugs on the eyes like crazy.

IMBB Rating:
1/5
Would I Recommend/Repurchase Hard Candy Stay in Line Blackest Black 12 Hr Mechanical Gel Eyeliner?
I haven’t come across such a dud in my life so far!! Even the products that I don’t find up to the mark, can be used for something else at least! But this dud straight went into the dust bin because I have no place for a terribly performing product in my vanity! Steer clear from this product ladies, don’t get it even if you get it for free!

Hard Candy Dark Chocolate Stay In Line 12 Hr Mechanical Gel Eyeliner
Hard Candy Black Metallic Stay In Line 12 Hr Mechanical Gel Eyeliner
Hard Candy Bold and Gorgeous Dare To Flick Felt Tip Liner
Hard Candy Bold and Gorgeous High Drama Innovation Felt Tip Liner
Hard Candy Sassy Eyes Sultry Eyeshadow Palette
Hard Candy Natural Eyes Neutral Eyeshadow Palette
Lakme Glide on Eye Colour Metallic Black
Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer
Colorbar 001 Pure Black All-Day Waterproof Gel Eyeliner
L’Oreal Paris Super Liner 24 Hour Waterproof Gel Eyeliner
Lakme Absolute Gel Addict Gel Eyeliner Must-Have
It Cosmetics No-Tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner – Black
L’Oreal Paris Double Extend Mascara Blackest Black
Milani Eye Tech Extreme Liquid Eyeliner – Blackest Black

IMBB RECOMMENDS

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *