L’Oreal Super Liner Automatic Slim Liner in Black Review

L’Oreal Super Liner Automatic Slim Liner in Black Review

Hello everyone,

I am on a marathon review phase and I am enjoying every bit of it. My last review was a gift and continuing with that phase, this was a recent gift from a dear friend of mine. Knowing my love for make-up, it has always been an easy gifting choice for friends. I do not mind making my friends’ lives easier any given day.


Moving on with the review, I have something other than lipstick and skin care to review today. This is the L’Oreal Super Liner in the shade Black, but it is one unique variant, known as automatic slim liner. Read on to know how this fared for me.


The pencil is a very slim one which is in a twist-up form. It has a plastic golden colored cap which is pretty strong and shuts with a click. I would like to draw special attention to how slim the pencil is. I have attached a picture where you can check how slim it is compared to our Faces pencil. I might call it a size zero among pencils. Might be an issue for some to get proper control, but for me it is fine.

L'Oreal black liner 3


It is slightly dry on swatching on my wrist and the liner is so slim that I have already ended up breaking the tip twice.

L'Oreal black liner 2


Rs. 650/- (could not find the quantity).

My Experience with L’Oreal Super Liner Automatic Slim Liner in Black:

I feel like banging my head when I make a wrong purchase myself, but when it is a gift, it is like a product I can play with. It is like my toy. When I got this surprise gift from a sweet friend of mine, I was so happy. Not just because it was a gift but because she took the pain to find something unique for me.

As for the liner, it is the thinnest and the most delicate liner I have come across. It comes in a twist-up form so I make sure I twist up only as much required, but still I go back and forth to build the intensity which breaks off the tip. It has helped me to draw thin lines on my lid and also for the days when I like to line only the outer third of my eyelid.

L'Oreal black liner 4

The staying power is average. On my waterline, it stayed on for an hour and on my lids, it was there for about 3 hours. I am not too impressed with this as the price we pay is high but the results are below average. I would have been considerate if it was a unique color, but a black liner with poor pigmentation and limited staying power is a no-no!

Pros of L’Oreal Super Liner Automatic Slim Liner in Black:

  • Helps to draw thin line.

Cons of L’Oreal Super Liner Automatic Slim Liner in Black:

  • Pricey.
  • Low staying power.
  • Poor pigmentation.
  • Slim body might cause grip problem.

Swatch on bare skin:

L'Oreal black liner 5

IMBB Rating:


Brown eyes

Will I Repurchase/Do I Recommend L’Oreal Super Liner Automatic Slim Liner in Black?

NO! for both!!!

L’Oreal Super liner Black Lacquer
L’Oreal Super Liner- Dark Sapphire
L’oreal Super Liner Black Amethyst
L’Oreal 24H Super Liner Waterproof Gel Eyeliner in Brown
Ulta Automatic Eye Liner – Raisin
Ulta Automatic Eye Liner – Moss
Faces Long Lasting Eyeliner Automatic
Arissa Lineart Automatic Eyeliner Pencil
NYX Slim Eye Pencil – Yellow
NYX Slim Lip liner Pencil Fuschia
NYX Slim Lip Pencil in Bloom
NYX Slim Eye Pencil in Sapphire
Revlon ColorStay Lip Liner – Chocolates
Lancome Liner Design
Maybelline Hyper Sharp Liner
NYX Liquid Eye Liner
Maybelline Lasting Drama Swirl Gel Liner
Lakme Black Impact Liner
Elle 18 Eye Liner – Black Out
MAC Liquid Eyeliner in Boot Black
Chambor Dream Liner in Black


14 thoughts on “L’Oreal Super Liner Automatic Slim Liner in Black Review

  1. ouch that is such a dud fr 650 bucks *spank* … thanks for the heads up.. good review Rashmita *clap*

  2. ohhh man they take soooo much cash and don’t give anything in return *cry* the shade isn’t very pigmented as well na… i mean not that dark black *nababana* *nababana*

  3. I have been using this eyeliner for around 8 months and i love it on my upper lash line!!! :-)! Not so much on my waterline! :-)!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *