Milk Makeup Silent Disco Eye Pigment Review

Skin tone: Fair-light, yellow-neutral undertones
Eye color: Brown eyes with oily eyelids

Hi friends,

Hope all of you are doing great. I am back to share my views about another Milk Makeup product with you all. This product is the perfect replacement of loose eye pigments, especially for beginners. However, it definitely has some drawbacks; considering I am still at the beginner level when it comes to eye makeup, I find this product to be a bit tricky. Let’s read more about Milk Makeup Silent Disco Eye Pigment!

Milk Makeup Silent Disco Eye Pigment Review

Product Description:
What it is:
A vivid, highly pigmented cream eye shadow in a portable tube that delivers bold color in one swipe.
What it does:
Bring a pop of color to your look with Milk Makeup’s long-wearing Eye Pigment. It gives you tenacious color with a soft, silky texture, drying on quickly without creasing. Create a dimensional, long-lasting look that’s as refined or rebellious as you want—layer to intensify. Easily blendable, this shadow is perfect for giving lids a vibrant touch of color for everyday looks.

$24 for 0.34 Oz, excludes shipping and tax
Isododecane, Mica, Disteardimonium Hectorite, Trimethylsiloxysilicate, Silica, Polyethylene, Synthetic Fluophlogopite, Polyester-4, Aluminum Starch Octenylsuccinate, Sorbitan Sesquioleate, Trihydroxystearin, Synthetic Wax, Phenoxyethanol, Water, Propylene Carbonate, Tin Oxide. May Contain: Titanium Dioxide, Iron Oxides, Ferric Ferrocyanide, Chromium Oxide Greens, Carmine.

My Experience with Milk Makeup Silent Disco Eye Pigment:

The eye pigment comes in a white tube packaging with a flip top opening. The color of the font on packaging co-ordinates with the shade. So, it is easy to find a purple or a brown tube even from the pool of eye pigments as the bright shade name make it easy. Overall, the packaging is quite small, sleek, and travel-friendly.

how to use eye pigment

My shade “Silent Disco” is defined as a brown while it looks metallic-sparkly brown on my skin tone with slightly blackish tint at times. After black, brown is my most favorite color for eye liners or kohls, hence it was not tough to choose this shade. Moreover, this is such a unique brown pigment with the perfect balance of black-golden tint, creamy texture and glittery shine.

eye pigment shade name

I also own Rave from this range. I love both of these for how they impart a sparkly finish, but I find these to be a bit tricky when I use these as all-over lid colors; maybe because of their drying texture. However, when worn as an eye liner, Silent Disco gives a perfect, glittery and smooth finish. The fact that I need not clean the mess up after using these glittery eye products is quite relieving. Needless to say, one swipe imparts intense brown pigmentation with a metallic sheen.

eye pigment packaging

Silent Disco comes up smoothly and looks saturated on my oily eyelids without any primer, though I need a primer to maintain the finish. Oh yes, it is certainly a budge-proof, transfer proof and waterproof formula, but sadly it comes up cakey and clings to fine lines if proper care with a primer isn’t taken. I find it a bit hard to apply on my eyelids as it appears a bit uneven and cakey whether I apply it with my fingers or a brush. You may blame my average makeup skills or lack of practice, but I never get a smooth, flawless base with this eye pigment.

cap eye pigment

I think unless you are a pro at applying eye makeup, there is no chance you can escape from these issues. Moreover it applies as molten butter and effortlessly slips on skin but then it dries on to a adamant stain which might start flaking off or chipping off with multiple swipes. This is not a major issue as one small drop of the product provides full color payoff. But, for a girl like me, who is still struggling to correct her winged eyeliner, it becomes hard to get smooth finish as less is more with this product. By the time I start filling in my winged liner, the product dries and becomes a stain making it tricky for me to maintain a smooth, flawless finish.

tube packaging eye pigment

Even if it appears beginner-friendly, it is not as easy as it appears! Anyway, I definitely love its intense color pay off and budge-proof long lasting wear time as it manages to stay intact without any chipping and/or fading for as long as 7+ hours. It comes off easily too with any oil based cleanser or makeup remover. Overall, I would definitely recommend it to beauty addicts who love to try different glittery eye products.

eye pigment swatches

eotd for eye pigment

Let’s sum up pros and cons:

Pros of Milk Makeup Silent Disco Eye Pigment:

• An intensely creamy and unique brown eye pigment
• Does not look frosty
• Imparts full color pay off in one gentle swipe
• A little drop imparts full color
• Easily spreadable
• Dries into a budge proof stain
• Does not smudge, transfer or feather
• Completely waterproof
• Stays intact for good 7+ hours
• Can be worn on bare eyes as a liner
• Works well as an all over eyelid color with a primer
• Portable, travel-friendly packaging

Cons of Milk Makeup Silent Disco Eye Pigment:

• Limited shades
• Might dry up and appear flaky
• Feathers around fine lines and crease
• Sometimes appears flaky and cakey even with a primer
• Clings to fine line
• Not a very forgiving finish and formula
• Not for beginners
• Price
IMBB Rating: 3.8/5

Milk Makeup Rave Eye Pigment
Milk Makeup Oil Lip Stain – Tude
Milk Makeup Name Drop Lip Color Review
Milk Makeup Dark Brew Gel Brow Review
Dr. Andrew Weil for Origins Mega Mushroom Skin Relief Lotion
L’Oreal Paris 210 Disco Ball Dazzle Infallible Mega Gloss
Coloressence High Pigment Matte Pencil Disco Pink HP-3
Essence Metallic Effect Mono Eye Shadow in 26 Disco Queen
Colorbar Glitterati Top Coat Disco Gold
How to Use Pigments
Makeup Revolution London Grandeur Pure Pigment for Beginners
Inglot #37 AMC Pure Pigment Eye Shadow


2 thoughts on “Milk Makeup Silent Disco Eye Pigment Review

  1. Ohh no .. Had high expectations from this product .. Sadly user friendliness is a big issue one cannot overlook

    But on another note, ur eyeliner wing is perfection!!! Bravo !! ????

    1. Thank you neha.. <3 coming from you means a lot dear :* talking abt this product, yeah it seems as replacement of loose pigments for no fall outs thankfully but its not an easy task.

Leave a Reply to Neha A Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *