Whenever I would see these NYC chubby shadow sticks, I used to ignore them mostly because of my prejudice against this brand, NYC; not that I have anything against it, but somehow, I found it not worth my money and would not give its products a second glance. But, this time, I decided to overcome my skepticism and buy some of the products. And, I am glad I decided to try this product because it was a win–win. Keep reading to know more about it!
Product Description:
Incredible staying power inspired by the city that never sleeps!
Want round the clock color that never fades or creases? This chubby, waterproof eye shadow delivers vibrant color for up to 24HR wear! In eleven on trend shades perfect for any look, just twist, glide and go!
Ingredients:
Not mentioned
Price:
$3
My Experience with NYC City Proof 24 Hour Eye Shadow in Murray Hill Champagne:
Shadow sticks are very handy and easy to use for beginners. When I am in a rush, I don’t find myself reaching for palettes or quads, but just a cream shadow or liner which I can apply easily on my lids and smudge out. At times, I use them as kohl or eye liner to keep things interesting and use some other color on my water line instead of the good old black. This product, in similar manner, can be used in several ways and just for $3, one gets to put one product to multiple uses.
Packaging: It is a chubby shadow stick with a twist up mechanism. It has a clear cap and outer covering of the stick represents the color of the shade.
Texture: It is not very creamy, but works in favor since it does not smudge or smear that easily. But, is easy to apply on the lids without much tugging or pulling; however, if one wants a smokey look or a more blended look, one has to work faster since it settles within a matter of seconds and does not budge after that.
Color: Very pretty champagne shade with gold undertones.
Pigmentation: Very good pigmentation. I gently swiped it on my palm and it gave a good color pay off. Two swipes are enough to get an intense eye look. A normal blending brush or fingertips are enough to get the desired color, but on darker lids, it might not be so obvious. So, for darker skin toned beauties, it is advisable to conceal the darkness and may be apply a darker shade underneath to make this shadow more apparent. It can be used as an eyeshadow base and increase wear time of not so good eyeshadows. It can be used on the water line, but we all know that lighter shades don’t last that long and need to be replied.
Wear Time: Entire day or rather 9 to 5 working hours. It is one of those products which do not require primer to increase their wear time or intensify the look.
Conclusion: It claims to be water proof, smudge proof and tear proof and trust me, it is! Once set in place, it does not move and one needs a good makeup remover to remove it.
Pros of NYC City Proof 24 Hour Eye Shadow in Murray Hill Champagne:
• Nice, twist up, chubby stick – easy to store or carry.
• Beautiful color which will look well on all skin tones.
• Can be used as on waterline and as an eye brightener.
• Very good pigmentation.
• Does not crease or spread.
• Smudge proof and water proof.
• Can be used in several ways.
• Definitely worth the money.
• Works well as an eyeshadow base.
• Available in several shades and all are good except the purple one – don’t buy that.
Cons of NYC City Proof 24 Hour Eye Shadow in Murray Hill Champagne:
• Maybe the ingredients list should have been there.
Would I Repurchase NYC City Proof 24 Hour Eye Shadow in Murray Hill Champagne?
Yes, as soon as I finish this one, would love to buy other shades as well. It is a very versatile product and a must have in vanity. I recommend it to all my readers.
IMBB Rating:
4.7/5
NYC City Duet The Rivington Reds 2in1 Lipcolor
NYC City Proof Twistable Intense Lip Color Fulton St Fuchsia
NYC Liquid Lip Shine Lip Gloss 574 City’s Clear
Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Night Cap Overnight Perfector
L’Oreal Paris Bronzed Taupe Infallible 24 HR Eyeshadow
L’Oreal Infallible 24 HR Eye Shadow – Tender Caramel 033
Lakme Absolute Gel Stylist Nail Paint – Pink Champagne
OPI Nail Lacquer – Chicago Champagne Toast
Crabtree and Evelyn Summer Hill Hand Therapy
Very versatile product. Such good value for money. 🙂