Smudgeproof Kajal: Ask IMBB

Ask IMBB Gang

Nayana asks:

Hello everyone,

I am looking for waterproof and smudge proof kajal and mascara with long staying power. I am planning to buy Lotus Herbals kajal, please help me to make a decision which one to pick?

Thank you all in advance :*

Good Smudge Proof Liquid Eyeliners below Rs 1000
L’Oreal Paris Kajal Magique
L’Oreal Paris Color Riche Le Kohl – Midnight Black
L’Oreal Paris Super Liner 24 Hour Waterproof Gel Eyeliner
L’oréal Paris Glam Shine Balmy Gloss – Lychee Lust
L’Oreal Paris Color Riche Nutri Shine Lipstick in Old Rose
L’Oreal Paris Glam Shine Balmy Gloss – Passion Fruit Perfect
L’Oreal Paris Ideal Balance Unifying and Balancing Foundation in Nude Beige
L’Oreal Paris Infallible Lipstick in Enduring Berry
Lakme Eyeconic Kajal
Faces Cosmetics Kajal
Shahnaz Husain Herbal Kajal

madam gupshup forums

Smudgeproof Kajal: Ask IMBB Overall rating: 0 out of 5 based on 0 reviews.
Review Title
Review Content


35 thoughts on “Smudgeproof Kajal: Ask IMBB

  1. If you have watery eyes, oily skin or tend to touch the eyes now nd then , I would not advice you to buy lotus kajal as on me they smudge easily. You can try lakme eyeconic kajal as well as colorbal smudgeproof kohl. Both are awesome. Dont smudge at all and waterproof tooo.

  2. There are quite a few options depending on how much you want to spend. If you want to spend less than Rs. 500 then you can see:
    1. Faces long wear pencil in solid black and faces superlongwear kohl
    2. maybelline colossal kajal
    3. lakme eyeconic
    4. loreal magique kajal
    5. bourjois contour clubbing pencil
    6. revlon kohls
    7. colorbar kohl pencil
    8. chambor kajal

    If you can spend more than Rs. 500 then :
    1. Mac engraved
    2. Bobbi brown pencil ( dont remember the name but it’s reviewed here)
    3. Estee Lauder Eye Pencil (I use this and it’s ah-mazing!)
    4. Clinique Quickliner Intense (Used this too and it’s gorgeoussss!)
    5. Chanel also has a pencil but don’t know much about it.
    6. Lancome Kohl (that’s also amazing)

    That’s all I know.. hope it helps 😀

      1. anchal your right now iam confused *scared* *scared* 😛 😛 😛 but going to read review and then i will buy *happy dance* *happy dance* *happy dance*

        1. hahaha! sorry if you got confused. my aim was only to tell u which all are there in the market 🙂
          and i know so much about kohls because thats the only makeup i use 😛 😛

          1. dnt b sorry…… *puchhi* i loved your list……. *happy dance* *happy dance* *happy dance* *happy dance* you guys really helped me *puchhi* *puchhi* *clap* *clap* *clap* *thankyou* *thankyou* *thankyou* *thankyou*

    1. So many options..!! Lolzz.. 😀 .. i use bobbi brown gel liner in waterline and smudge it a bit with mac’s espresso eyeshadow .. i get the most amazing finish and lasts very long.. *pompom*

  3. Hi, I have oily skin and Lotus kajal smudges under my eyes. I will advise you to go for Colossal or Iconic.. both never smudges on me 🙂

  4. loved the list by Nandini..
    I have used :
    1. Faces long wear pencil in solid black and faces superlongwear kohl
    2. maybelline colossal kajal
    3. loreal magique kajal

    loved all 3… faces one is very soft.. finishes soon.. maybellinge and loreal are equally great!! however i like loreal more… 🙂 Lotus Herbals smudges badly on me too! 😀 panda eyes

    1. panda eyes rofl rofl rofl i am definitely not going to buy lotus herbal now *nababana* *nababana* Colossal or Iconic are two option which iam liking *happydance* *happydance* *happy dance* *happy dance* *happy dance*
      *thankyou* *thankyou* jyoti

  5. try the new l’oreal sister was a no kajal person and even colossal and eyeconic cud not change her views…she tried this one and is absolutely loving it…it did not smudge even after a night’s sleep..also she has a habit of rubbing her eyes..and it didnt smudge on her even then…quite a miracle for her…hope it was helpful 🙂 🙂

    1. *thankyou* kadambari…. loved your name *puchhi* i will read all review… Colossal and Iconic on my wish list…. *happy dance* *happy dance* *happydance* *happydance*

  6. Lotus one gave me panda eyes too. *cry* *cry* Maybelline Collosal Kajal is good and apart from that Lakme Absolute one is also very good. Am currently using d lakme absolute one *happydance* *happydance* and i just love it..

    1. i dnt want panda eyes *nababana* *nababana* 😛 😛 will buy Maybelline Collosal Kajal and Lakme eyeconic *happy dance* *happy dance* *happy dance*

  7. For mascara I would suggest Estee Lauder Sumptuous Extreme (reviewed by RATi) is fantastic -it not waterproof but unless you intend to swim with this on, there is no issue – it does not budge, does not sting, stays put entire day, just a couple of strokes give wonderful results.

  8. *thankyou* *thankyou* *thankyou* everyone. appreciate *jai ho* *jai ho*
    love u all…… *puchhi* *puchhi* *thankyou* for solving my problem…… IMBB rocksssss *happy dance* *happy dance* *happy dance* *happy dance* *happy dance* i decided to buy Maybelline Collosal Kajal and Lakme Eyeconic one……. *jalwa* *jalwa* *jogging* *jogging* *jogging* *jogging*

      1. yes yes *oye balle* *oye balle* *pompom* *pompom* *happy dance* *happy dance*
        IMBB ki jai *jai ho* *jai ho* *jai ho* *jai ho*

  9. I have used almost all the kajals which claims to be smudgeproof, but trust me Girls *announce* , the best one I have come across is the In color rollon Pencil…………. It is not at all expensive and super-duper smudge Proof. *clap*

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *