Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes Matte Brown 25L Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil Review

Heylo everyone,

This eyeliner is part of my Black Friday/makeup haul from Sephora and since it belongs to a high-end brand I had high expectations from it, but I have mixed feelings about this product. Read on further to know why:

Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes Matte Brown

Product Description:
This highly pigmented waterproof, smudge- and fade-resistant eyeliner is formulated to glide on effortlessly and withstand the most extreme conditions. It stays put on eyelids without melting for precise application and intense color throughout the day. Aqua Eyes doubles as a shadow – just smudge it out.


My Experience with Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes Matte Brown 25L Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil:

After “black,” my next favorite eyeliner color is “brown” because it can be used in multiple ways and it gives a softer look to the eyes. I especially like to use brown eyeliner to create brown smokey eyes or use it on the waterline when I want to do dark eye makeup so that my eyes don’t appear small.

Packaging:  This product comes in a sharpen-able pencil form. The pencil has a shiny brown finish and a cap on top.

Texture:  Super soft and buttery, like a baby’s bottom 😛 but not smooth to the point that it keeps running and smudging (we all hate those raccoon eyes). It applies with equal ease on both eyelids and water line without any tugging or pulling. It gives a matte finish as claimed by the product.

MUFE eyeliner

Color: I love the color – brown with red undertones. It looks very pretty on eyelids especially when used to create brown smokey eyes; however, it does not appear that intense on water line and looks like a dull black color unless darkened with brown powder eyeshadow.

Pigmentation:  One swipe gives a brown color, opaque streak and one need not go over water line or lids again and again to get full coverage – one swipe is enough. However, the intensity of the color does not increase appreciably over multiple swipes and hence it futile to do so.

MUFE eyeliner swatch

Staying Power:  Once applied, do not mess with it for at least 15 seconds and that’s it; enjoy brown smudge-proof look for an entire day or as long as one does not mess with it too much. It gives a good wear time on water line as well, but the wear time might vary from person to person. One can use a loose powder on the lids or a primer to prevent it from creasing or smudging. It gives a better wear time than most drug store mascaras.

MUFE eyeliner swatch

Pros of Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes Matte Brown 25L Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil:

  • Long, slender pencil with generous amount of product.
  • Texture is super creamy and buttery.
  • Smudge proof and water proof for an entire day.
  • Matte finish.
  • Good pigmentation, one swipe is enough.
  • No fragrance.
  • Gives a better wear time than most drugstore eyeliners.

Cons of Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes Matte Brown 25L Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil:

  • Needs to be sharpened.
  • Intensity of brown color could have been better.
  • Doesn’t appear deep brown on the waterline.
  • Pricey.

Would I Repurchase/Recommend Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes Matte Brown 25L?

No, because whatever said and done, I like my khols to be extra intense and pigmented so that it stands out on my face. All those who don’t mind the $19 price tag and can compromise on the intensity of color, should check out this eyeliner.

IMBB Rating:

Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil – Matte Black
Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil 7L Turquoise and 3L Iridescent Navy Blue
Make Up For Ever Aqua Look Collection 5 Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils
Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes Collection Set
Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes 18 L Burgundy
Best Liquid Black Eyeliners Available in India: A Collection
Make Up For Ever Ink Liner Matte Liquid Eyeliner
Lakme Absolute Shine Line: Black Eyeliner
Colorbar Precision Waterproof Eyeliner


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *