Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil in The Black Earl

Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil in The Black Earl

Hello Beauties,

Today, I’ll be reviewing one of my most favorite liner which is Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil in shade The Black Earl! I love soft, smudged eye looks a lot and this was the main reason to get this liner pencil.

Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil in The Black Earl

Product Description:

Smokey, smooth, seductive, the Smokey Eyes Pencil with an integrated brush applicator and a soft, easy-to-blend texture creates endless creative opportunities for effective smokey eyes make-up styles. As if you‘ve just stepped out of a fashion magazine!  Available in three trendy colors. – The Black Earl – smokey black liner with silver shimmer, Gloria Greynor – silverish greyish color and lastly Its A Pleasure, Treasure – bluish grey in color.

Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil3

My Take on Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil in The Black Earl:

The shade I got is “The Black Earl” and its a gorgeous deep black color with visible silver shimmer! I totally adore this shade! The pigmentation is lovely and you need only one swipe to get that deep color! The shimmer is very fine and not visible much on the eyes, so it can be worn during day time as well. The pencil is extremely soft and creamy and glides like a dream on the lash line. I have even used this on my lower lash line and works well.  It has never irritated my eyes though I would not recommend it for waterline due to obvious shimmer.

rati beauty ad

On smudging, it gives a glorious greyish color which looks lovely! Once set, the liner stays on me for the entire day until I remove it with a makeup remover. So, the staying power is pretty awesome! Though the color may fade a little after 6 to 7 hours, but it is still very visible.

The pencil comes with its own smudger which makes it easy to get that smokey soft look in minutes! I love this smudger! Initially, I did not expect much from it, but I was pleasantly surprised as the smudger is of top quality! Its not like those cheap rubber-type smudgers, but its flexible enough to move around the corners of eyes and at the same time firm enough to smudge the liner without tugging at the lids. I use this smudger a lot and it works with all kinds of liners 🙂 Don’t need a separate smudger brush now!

Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil2

This is how it looks on me

Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil5

Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil5

Pros of Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil in The Black Earl:

  • Pigmentation is good and only swipe is enough for that gorgeous color.
  • The pencil is extremely soft and creamy in texture and glides on eyes.
  • The shimmer in the pencil is very fine and does not irritate the eyes in any way.
  • The pencil comes with its own smudger which is of fab quality!
  • Very reasonably priced.
  • Once set, it stays on the eyes for easily around 7 to 8 hours after which it fades a little but still its quite visible.

Cons of Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil in The Black Earl:

  • Availability is the only con I can think of!

IMBB Rating:



3 to 4 swiss francs, i.e., around 200 INR.

Do I Recommend Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil in The Black Earl?

Totally, I recommend this one to everyone! Its a must have for me!

Hope this review was helpful, until tomorrow, take care!

Catrice Ultimate Colour Lipstick in 130 Frozen Rose
Catrice Ultimate Colour Lipstick in 050 Princess Peach
Catrice Eyeshadow 300 Pink Rock Super Star
Catrice Eyeshadow Duo Miracle Heaven
Black Smokey Eye Tutorial
Smokey Eye: Brown Black Smokey Eye Tutorial
NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Black Bean
Estee Lauder Artist’s Eye Pencil Soft Smudge Black
NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Yoghurt Review, Swatches
Faces Cosmetics Long Wear Eye Pencil Review, Swatch, EOTD
Streetwear Metal Eyes Eye Pencil Shade ’Silver Lining’
Elle 18 Stylz Eye Pencil
Colorbar I Glide Eye Pencil
Bourjois Khol & Contour Eyeliner Pencil
Essence Black Mania Carbon Black Gloss Eye Pencil
Sunsilk Stunning Black Shine Shampoo


29 thoughts on “Catrice Smokey Eye Pencil in The Black Earl

    1. hey riddhima…!!! there was a serial named dill mill gayye which was aired in starone… there main female character name was riddhima…. i just loved that serial… ur name reminds me of my dmg…. 😉 😛 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *