Deborah Milano 24 Ore Eye Pencil Shade 251 Black

Deborah Milano 24 Ore Eye Pencil Shade 251 Black


I have long been a silent spectator in IMBB world, as my laziness prevented me from picking up my cam and my stuff and getting 2-3 nice pics for a review, but finally, the temptation to contribute something in my favourite blog overcame and here it is.This is my first product review. Hope you all like it and find it helpful.

Deborah Milano 24ore Eye Pencil

Product Being Reviewed:

Deborah Milano 24 Ore Eye Pencil in Shade 251[Black].

The one I am reviewing is a solid black color shade 251.

I found that the price range of this product is around €5.90 € 7.40 abroad, from some review websites. In India, Urban touch and Healthkart sells this product for around 230-240 bucks, and lesser, if some sale is going on. I have found Deborah Milano products featuring in Fashion and You sales as well.

What the Company Website Claims:
“An incredibly soft-textured pencil that highlights the outline of the eyes with precision, for flawless long-lasting color. Dermatologist tested.”

It is available in 8 shades, but I found only a maximum of 4 shades [in Urban touch].


Hydrogenated coco-glycerides, polyethylene,cera microcrystallina, hydrogenated tallow acid, dimyristyl tartrate, tri-c12-13 alkyl citrate, polyglyceryl-2 oleate, sorbic acid, ethylparaben, bht, ci 77499, ci 77510.

Hydrogenated coco-glycerides are Fatty particles with lightly emulsifying properties, which improve product consistency, and bind moisture on skin surface. Polyethylene can be used to dilute other solids, or to increase the thickness of the lipid (oil) portion of cosmetics and personal care products.

I was intrigued by the terms cera microcrystalline which is MICROCRYSTALLINE WAX derived from petroleum used to lessen the brittleness of stick products and add strength and stability to lipsticks.

Hydrogenated tallow acid caused me some concerns as it was mentioned that it might have been derived from animals. Dimyristyl tartrate, polyglyceryl-2 oleate and TRI-C12-13 ALKYL CITRATE are Skin-Conditioning Agent used as an Emollient. Sorbic Acid and Potassium Sorbate kill microorganisms, or prevent or retard their growth and reproduction, and thus protect cosmetics and personal care products from spoilage. BHT acts as an antioxidant by preventing or slowing the deterioration of cosmetics and personal care products caused by chemical reactions with oxygen. CI 77499 is an inorganic colorant primarily composed of iron oxides (ferrous-ferric oxide). CI 77510 is Ferric ferrocyanide is an iron-based inorganic colorant also known as Prussian blue; one of the first synthetic pigments. Both the colorants are known human respiratory toxicant. It also contains parabens, so I guess this is not a daily use-instead-of-kajal product.

Shelf Life: 2 years.


My Experience with Deborah Milano 24 Ore Eye Pencil Shade 251 Black:

This is a nice soft-tipped eye pencil and I love the jet black matte color it gives. It does not come off very easily with swipes and it can be smudged for a smokey eye effect. It removes very easily with cleansing milk, though I usually use my herbal face-soap to wash it off. It has a decent staying power of 2-3 hours after which it starts fading though it still manages to give a dark-eyed look. I have applied it over my eyelids and along my waterline, and it doesn’t sting.



Pros of Deborah Milano 24 Ore Eye Pencil

  • Easy to apply.
  • Jet black color [keeps my eyes dark even after a bath].
  • Doesn’t sting my eyes.
  • Smudges easily for a smokey eye effect.
  • Stays for around 2-3 hours without touch-ups [a great thing for my oily oily skin!].

Cons of Deborah Milano 24 Ore Eye Pencil

  • Contains parabens and toxic colorants, but I guess that is a concern for most makeup products!
  • Contains ingredients that may be derived from animals, so vegans beware!
  • Doesn’t come with a sharpener and this needs sharpening very very often!
  • Availability might be an issue – I got this online.

Overall Rating:

3.5 out of 5 [for having no sharpeners and parabens].

Would I Buy This Again:

this again: Of course, I love blacky black eye pencils and this one is a good purchase as the price is decent and the effect is good, so until I come across a completely non-toxic jet black eye pencil, this is a sure-buy. I am also planning to try other colors in this range, that I found in Urban Touch.

Please tell me if this review was helpful or not.

Also Read:
Deborah Milano Definitive Volume and Curl Mascara Marrone Brown
Deborah Milano Euphoric Shine Gloss
Deborah Milano Kajal Pencil
Deborah Milano Trio Hi-Tech Dry n Wet Eye Shadow – Gold Fever
Deborah Milano 7 Days Long Nail Enamel in No 39 Review Swatches
Deborah Blush Rosa Pesca Review, Swatch
NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Black Bean
Estee Lauder Artist’s Eye Pencil Soft Smudge Black
NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Yoghurt Review, Swatches
Faces Cosmetics Long Wear Eye Pencil Review, Swatch, EOTD
Streetwear Metal Eyes Eye Pencil Shade ’Silver Lining’
Elle 18 Stylz Eye Pencil
Colorbar I Glide Eye Pencil
Bourjois Khol & Contour Eyeliner Pencil
E.L.F Shimmer Eye Pencils – Review & Swatches
Faces Long Wear Eye Pencils Review, Shades, Swatches
Oriflame Wild West Couture Eye Pencil
Bourjois Contour Clubbing Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil Review, Swatch
Amway Attitude Eye Pencil: Kajal Coal
Tips and Toes Stay On Eye Pencil Sparkling Black
MAC Feline Kohl Power Eye Pencil Review, EOTD, Experiment
Which Eyepencil/Kajal Stays Without Smudging: Ask IMBB Gang
Avon Eye Pencils, Lip Glosses and Nail Paints Haul
Street Wear Eye Pencil in Black Currant
Maxfactor Eye pencils and Lip liner- Review
Bourjois Paris Effet Smoky Eye Pencil and Effet 3D Max Lip Gloss
Nichido Girls Night Out Eye Pencil In Pink Diamond
NYX Slim Eye Pencil – Copper & Emerald City, Review & swatches
7 Eyeliner Pencils I am Loving These Days
Oriflame Beauty Eye Intensity Pencil Review, Photos, Swatches


26 thoughts on “Deborah Milano 24 Ore Eye Pencil Shade 251 Black

  1. good review :yes: :yes: :yes: if i’m not wrong taps had also reviewed one of these pencils in some color ?:) ?:) ?:)
    i’ll give it a pass…..parabens or no parabens….i mainly look for the staying power in my pencils…..since it fails there, no no :nono: :nono:

    1. Thanks Kanika :toothygrin:
      yeah, staying power is a problem, but i m a touch-up addict, always do it every 2-3 now its not a problem..
      but yeah, i m still waiting for my HG blacky black

  2. smudges???? :waiting: :waiting: touch ups??? :scream: :scream: thnx for the review dear :thumbsup: … i was eyeing this… not any more.. :nonono: :nonono: .. am happy with my new colorbar i glide :jalwa:

    1. u bought colorbar suks???? :yes: :yes: :yes: :yes: good girl… buy lakme glide on…..they also as good as colorbar ones :woot: :woot: :woot: :woot: :woot:

      1. :nono: :nono: i got these from pantaloons near my home …. lakme glide on wala in iridescent blue i have…but i cant carry it :(( …. only sometimes i use it at night,topped up with loads of kohl :secret2: :secret2: …but the staying power of colorbar wala is really great… i got it in brown (i prefer browns to blacks 😀 )

    2. Thanks Sukanya, yeah staying power is definitely a prblm..
      My FACES eye pencil in purple shade easily outstays this one..
      I would ve loved to try Maybelline, but for the fact that I am against animal testing..:(

        1. Colorbar i-glide and Bourjois khol and contour are my next targets.. :worship:
          I only wish Colorbar was available in all shades online, their website has such a limited collection and its not available in ma place.. :waaa:

            1. healthkart seems to have expanded their make up collection.i just bought some make up from there n got a discount! Bot deborah s blue color pencil.i like the feel of it.

  3. Dear readers has Deborah Milano’s 24 Ore Eye Pencil at a good discount. There are attractive discounts on other cosmetics as well. Do let us know if there’s a specific shade/product you want…

    Shop smart! 🙂

  4. @ Taps- free shipping, variety n all is good but the time they take to deliver is not cool at all… i wish they could fine tune their delivery processes and their customer care. will try healthkart next time, i hope they live upto their promises!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *