Maybelline SuperStay 24 Hour 2-Step Lip Color – Cinnamon Stay

Maybelline SuperStay 24 Hour 2-Step Lip Color – Cinnamon Stay

Hi People,

I’m back with a lip colour review after a long time. I was looking for a “long stay” lip colour to wear with sarees and salwars.  I wear my lipsticks, tinted lip balms, etc., for work and when I go out.  In these cases, I don’t mind touching up throughout the day, but on festival days and when I go for weddings, parties, etc., I don’t want touching up throughout the day.  I tried lip stains, they were okay, but the look was not natural.  With those, I felt like I had used felt pen on my lips.  At the end, it came down to Maybelline and the 24-hour super stay lip colour they had to offer.

Maybelline SuperStay 24 Hour 2 Step Lip Color Cinnamon Stay

I bought this from a “Priceline”store in Melbourne.  There was a range of colours available, and after trying some and also after deciding which colour will suit most of my sarees and salwars, I decided to purchase “Cinnamon Stay.”  It is a nude brown colour and I visualised myself wearing it and it did look good enough to spend $21.95.  Maybelline had a 16-hour ColorStay Lip Colour before this and now they have either re-formulated or just re-packaged it into a “24-hour colour.”

This is a two-step formula because it contains the lip colour at one end and a lip balm on the other.  The lip colour is to be used first and then the lip balm should be used on top of it.

Product Description:

Why You Would Love Maybelline SuperStay 24 Hour 2-Step Lip Color – Cinnamon Stay:

Meet the 24-hour lipcolor that stretches the limits of long wear:

  • Micro-Flex formula glides on and looks gorgeous all day.
  • No crumbling, no caking, no fading, no feathering, no transferring.
  • Two-step lipcolor in one pack.
  • 30 long-lasting shades.

Cinnamon Stay

Directions For Use:

Apply the liquid color to your clean, bare lips. Allow a full two minutes to dry, then apply ultra-conditioning balm to seal in softness.  Reapply balm as needed. Remove with an oil-based makeup remover.


AUD 21.95.

My Take on Maybelline SuperStay 24 Hour 2-Step Lip Color – Cinnamon Stay:

The lip colour is of a thick consistency and is very well pigmented.  As soon as you apply it on to the lips, it feels heavy. It dries quickly and makes your lips feel dry. However, as soon as you apply the balm, it gives a nice glossy finish. It also looks more natural after application of the balm. With regards to the staying power, this lip colour is definitely a winner.

Even when I applied only one coat of the lip colour and then topped it off with the balm, it stayed on throughout the party.  I didn’t have to re-touch even with constant eating and drinking. After coming home, I couldn’t remove it just with water and tissue paper, I had to use oil-based makeup remover.  Even after using oil-based remover, there was still a light tint of colour, which only went off the following morning.

Cinnamon Stay 1

It does what it says; it almost stayed on for at least 15-20 hours, even though I removed it at the end of it. There is actually no need for any makeup to stay on for 24 hours. I tried using the balm on top of some other lip colours I had, but it didn’t work well, it just got stained. So this balm is for specific use with this lip colour.

Another thing worthy of mention is that to get this swatch, I applied a little bit on my hands and had so much trouble trying to wash it off. My only worry is that to have made this lip color so long lasting, they would have used loads of chemicals and strong formulations, so this is definitely not something I’d use on a day-to-day basis.


Pros of Maybelline SuperStay 24 Hour 2-Step Lip Color – Cinnamon Stay:

  • This is a long-stay lip colour, which delivers what it promises.
  • The texture is more natural compared to lip stains.
  • The balm gives a more natural glossy sheen.
  • Stays put throughout eating, drinking and constant cups of coffee sipping.

Cons of Maybelline SuperStay 24 Hour 2-Step Lip Color – Cinnamon Stay:

  • Compared to other lipsticks, this product is more prone to drying and flaking if the lip balm is not reapplied.
  • The tube that holds the balm is quite flimsy, not well packaged.
  • Priced high at AUD 21.95.
  • Does not smell good, has a synthetic fragrance.
  • Because of the thick and long-stay formulation, it might contain strong chemicals, so shouldn’t be used regularly.

IMBB Rating:


I am fairly satisfied with this product, even though it has its drawbacks. Will repurchase it until I find a better long-lasting lip colour within my budget.

Maybelline SuperStay Lip Color
Maybelline Superstay Gloss Photos, Swatches
Maybelline Newyork Superstay Gloss 12H
Maybelline Colossal Kajal
Maybelline Diamond Glow Eyeshadow: Gray Pink
L’oreal 24 Hour Superliner Gel Eyeliner
Korres Wild Rose 24 Hour Moisturizing & Brightening Cream
Vaseline Total Moisture 24 hour Moisturizing Cream
Garnier Pure Active Spot Fighting 24 Hour Moisturiser
Maybelline Forever Metallics Metal Shine Lip Color Pencil
Oriflame Stay Glam Lip Colour
Revlon Renewist Lipcolor Lush Peony
Revlon Colorstay Overtime LipColor Photos, Swatches
REVLON Street Wear: Shine Divine Lip Color
Bobbi Brown Creamy Lip Color Rose Brown Review, Swatch, FOTD
Lakme Aquashine Lip Colour
Clinique High Impact Lip Colour Rosette
4 Must Have Classic Lakme Enrich Lip Color Shades
Wet n Wild Mega Last Lip Color
Maybelline Color Sensational Lipstick – Spicy Cinnamon
Fabindia Orange Cinnamon Face and Body Gel Scrub
NYX Powder Blush Cinnamon
The Bombay Store Cinnamon Soap


22 thoughts on “Maybelline SuperStay 24 Hour 2-Step Lip Color – Cinnamon Stay

  1. wow i’d love to try this! n yea u’re ryt, cant use such long stay ones unless v r ppl constantly facing the media which isnt the case! so yup, once in a while! but expensive eh even by maybelline standards!

  2. Yes True Sukanya,…im an accountant by profession so i dont have to have lipcolour on all the time…the normal lippies I wear to work , I just touch up throughout the day….these are foe special occasions only …… :makeup:

  3. Nice review Supriya :yes: :yes:
    I have used Maybelline 16 hour lip colour (gloss actually) which had colour in one side
    and transparent gloss on other.There was one bright pink colour in that which i loved a lot.But they have discontinued that range in India now. :waaa: :waaa:
    This one looks good but i think it is not available in India yet 🙁 🙁

  4. this is lovely ! :yes: Supriya,i just want to u hv mentioned above that its drying and u need to top with the balm!,how long is the staying power of the lipbalm ? :worship:

    1. Thanks Sukanya…

      Initially I would apply two coats of the balm,..the lip balm does not have an impact on the lip colour… just gives sheen to the lipcolour…..I would say top up after about four hours …but this is not necessary ….just a way to make your lips look moist and not dry…

  5. I dont even remember how many people have recommended these. I loved the color your have reviewed. So easy to pull off. :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo:

  6. I loveee these kind of shades Supriya ,its very pretty..though I dnt remember seeing this range here :/ .would love to get atleast one shade frm this range

  7. That’s a very pretty shade. I’ve been on the hunt for the perfect bright shade for my face when I realized my regular nudes make me look really washed out. I live I Melbourne too 🙂

    1. Hi Sara,…..

      I live in canberra, bought this when I went to Melb,,,….this is available in all priceline stores …Nudes are good for everyday wear though

      1. I’m Melbourne as well! You did a very thorough review Supriya! I too am worried about the chemicals they would have to use to get it so long lasting, and agree also about there being no need for a lipstick to last 24 hrs! A bit like shellac nail polish that lasts 3 weeks. :-/

  8. vow.. d shade is super pretty supriya….but i totally agree wid u abt any makeup lasting 24 hrs n d chemicals dat go into it..

  9. Hey, sukanya! That is indeed a lovely shade. Next time you are in Australia, i recommend that you try to get lipsense. Maybelline has tried to copy it. My cousin sent some over and boy! Are they amazing! Very long lasting and they are vegan, cruelty free and actually make your lips better as you use them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *